New buildings get fall protection designed in. Somebody specifies the roof anchors, a structural engineer checks the loads, the installer provides certificates and a drawing, and the anchors go on the inspection register. Older buildings get none of that. They get a contractor on the roof looking for something solid to clip onto, and what they usually find is a vent pipe, a parapet coping stone or a rusted eyebolt with no paperwork.
I have refused work on roofs where the only anchor available was something a rigger described as “probably fine”. Probably is not a load rating.
Start by questioning whether you need an anchor at all
Personal fall arrest is near the bottom of the hierarchy for good reasons. It does nothing until somebody has already fallen, it relies on the anchor, the harness, the connectors and the rescue plan all working together, and a person who falls and is arrested can still be badly injured by the swing, the impact or by hanging in the harness.
In the United Kingdom, the Work at Height Regulations require you to avoid work at height where you can, then prevent falls, and only then minimise the distance and consequences of a fall. US law reaches the same order through OSHA’s fall protection requirements, which are set out on the OSHA fall protection pages. In an older building, that order matters more than usual. A temporary edge protection system, a mobile elevating work platform, or doing the job from inside through an opening may avoid the anchor problem entirely.
If you do need an anchor, a restraint system that physically stops the person reaching the edge is far better than an arrest system that catches them after they go over. Restraint loads on the anchor are much lower, and nobody ends up hanging.
What an anchor has to do
An anchor for fall arrest has to take a dynamic load, not just the weight of a person standing still. When an arrest system catches a fall, the anchor sees a sudden peak force, limited by the energy absorber but still far higher than body weight.
The numbers differ by jurisdiction. OSHA requires anchorages for personal fall arrest to support at least 5,000 pounds per employee attached, or to be designed, installed and used as part of a complete system that maintains a safety factor of at least two under the supervision of a qualified person. In Europe, anchor devices are tested to EN 795, which classifies them into types such as fixed structural anchors, rigid and flexible horizontal lines, and deadweight anchors. In the UK, BS 7883 gives the code of practice for selecting, installing, using and maintaining anchors conforming to EN 795.
The critical point is that an anchor device certified to EN 795 is only as strong as the structure it is fixed to. The certificate covers the device. It says nothing about the forty year old concrete slab you have just drilled into.
Why older structures are the hard case
The problem with an old building is not that it is weak. It is that you do not know what it is.
- Unknown construction. Roof decks may be lightweight concrete, woodwool slabs, timber boarding, asbestos cement sheeting or profiled metal on purlins that were never designed for point loads.
- Deterioration. Water ingress corrodes reinforcement, rots timber and loosens masonry. Parapet walls are often in poorer condition than the main structure because they take the weather from both sides.
- Undocumented alterations. Holes cut for services, removed walls, added plant loads and infilled openings are common, and the drawings, if any exist, rarely show them.
- Legacy anchors. Eyebolts and rails installed decades ago with no record of design, installation or testing.
- Fragile surfaces. Roof lights and fragile sheeting kill people through the roof, not over the edge. An anchor at the eaves does nothing for that.
The things people clip onto
The list of improvised anchors I have seen used includes vent stacks, aerial brackets, plant room handrails, lightning conductor tape, satellite dish mounts, cable trays, sprinkler pipes and window frames. None of these were designed to take an arrest load. Plant guardrails might look strong, but a guardrail is designed for a horizontal load from someone leaning on it, not the dynamic pull of an arrested fall.
Structural steel beams are often a legitimate option, provided a competent person confirms the member and its connections, and the beam clamp or sling used is rated for the purpose. That is a judgement, not an assumption.
Getting a reliable anchor into an old building
The safe route is boring and it costs money. Commission a competent person, often a structural engineer working with a specialist installer, to survey the roof and specify anchors for the actual structure. Where fixings go into masonry or concrete of unknown quality, proof load testing of installed anchors is normally part of the job, and BS 7883 sets out how testing should be approached in the UK. Get a drawing of anchor locations, the system type, the number of users each anchor is designed for, and installation and test certificates.
Where drilling into the structure is impossible or unwise, alternatives exist.
- Counterweight or deadweight anchors that sit on a flat roof without penetrating it, used only within the manufacturer’s limits on roof slope, surface and distance from the edge.
- Through bolted anchors with a plate on the underside of the slab, where the underside is accessible.
- Clamp anchors onto confirmed structural steel.
- Temporary freestanding edge protection that removes the need for an anchor at all.
Legacy anchors without paperwork should be treated as untested until proved otherwise. Either have them inspected and tested by a competent person or take them out of use and label them clearly.
Clearance and swing
An adequate anchor in the wrong place is still a problem. A fall arrest system needs enough clear distance below the person to deploy the energy absorber and stop them before they hit anything. That calculation includes the lanyard length, absorber deployment, harness stretch, the height of the person’s attachment point and a safety margin. On a low roof, a standard lanyard may not arrest a fall before the person hits the ground. Anchors placed well back from the edge also create a swing fall, where the arrested worker swings sideways into a wall or another structure.
Inspection, rescue and records
Permanent anchors need periodic inspection by a competent person, commonly at least once a year in the UK under BS 7883, and more often in harsh environments. Keep a register with each anchor’s location, type, rating, inspection date and result. Mark anchors on the roof itself so nobody has to guess.
Every arrest system needs a rescue plan before anyone goes up. A person hanging in a harness needs to be recovered quickly, and calling the fire service is not a plan on its own. Decide in advance how you will get someone down, with what equipment and by whom, and practise it.
Local regulation and a proper risk assessment decide the final answer for your building. What they will not accept is a contractor’s guess about what looks solid, because when that guess is wrong there is no second chance to correct it.