Most eye injuries I have dealt with in metalworking shops were not dramatic. Nobody lost an eye to an exploding wheel. What I saw, again and again, was a small hot particle from a grinder lodged in the cornea of somebody who was wearing safety glasses at the time, just not the right ones, or not worn properly, or pushed up on the forehead for a moment while they checked the work. The second most common was arc eye in a person who was not even welding.
Grinding and welding share a workshop, often share a bench, and the people doing them often swap between tasks in the same hour. The eye hazards are completely different, and that is where selection goes wrong.
Two different hazards in one bay
Grinding is a mechanical hazard. Fragments of metal and abrasive leave the wheel at speed, often hot, and travel in a fan that is wider than people expect. Wire brushes throw bristles. Cutoff discs shatter if they bind or are side loaded. The hazard comes from the front and from the sides, and it bounces off nearby surfaces.
Arc welding is mainly an optical hazard. The arc gives off intense ultraviolet, visible and infrared radiation. Ultraviolet exposure causes photokeratitis, better known as arc eye, which typically shows up hours after the exposure as the feeling of sand in the eyes, often waking people in the night. It usually heals, but it is painful and it is a clear sign that the controls failed. Welding also produces spatter and, once the helmet is lifted, slag chips from chipping and wire brushing, which brings the mechanical hazard straight back.
Reading the markings on European eyewear
In Europe, eye protectors are tested to EN 166, and the frame and lens markings tell you what the product is approved for. The mechanical strength letters are the ones that matter for grinding.
| Marking | Meaning | Where it can appear |
|---|---|---|
| S | Increased robustness, no high speed particle rating | Any protector |
| F | Low energy impact, 45 m/s | Spectacles, goggles, face shields |
| B | Medium energy impact, 120 m/s | Goggles and face shields |
| A | High energy impact, 190 m/s | Face shields only |
A letter T after the impact rating means the impact test was passed at extremes of temperature. Field of use symbols add further information, and for this work the important one is 9, which indicates resistance to molten metal and penetration of hot solids. A spectacle without a 9 can have hot grinding particles stick to and pit the lens, which is one reason spectacles in grinding areas look frosted after a few weeks.
Welding filters carry their own standards. Passive welding filters are covered by EN 169, automatic welding filters by EN 379, and helmets and hand shields by EN 175. An auto darkening filter shows both a light state and a dark state shade number.
The US approach
In the United States, OSHA requires eye and face protection under its personal protective equipment rules and points to ANSI Z87.1 as the consensus standard. Products that pass basic impact testing are marked Z87, and those that pass high impact testing are marked Z87+. Welding filters are marked with a W followed by the shade number. Common US practice, and most manufacturers’ instructions, treat a face shield as something worn over safety spectacles or goggles rather than on its own. The OSHA eye and face protection pages include the shade selection table for welding and cutting.
What to wear for grinding
For bench grinding and handheld angle grinding, the minimum I accept is wraparound spectacles or goggles with good side coverage, rated for impact. For anything beyond light, occasional work, add a face shield. The face shield deals with the larger fragments and a disc failure. The spectacles deal with the particles that get under the shield and the moment the shield is lifted.
Goggles give better protection than spectacles against particles coming from below and the sides, and a sealed goggle stops debris getting in around the frame. Their weakness is fogging. A fogged goggle gets pulled down onto the neck, and then the worker is unprotected. Look for anti fog coatings that are actually rated, indirect venting, and give people a way to clean lenses without dragging a gritty glove across them.
Two failure points come up repeatedly. The first is scratched lenses. Somebody wearing a lens they cannot see through properly will look over it or take it off. Replace spectacles as a consumable rather than waiting until they are useless. The second is prescription glasses. Ordinary prescription glasses are not safety eyewear. Provide prescription safety spectacles, or goggles designed to fit over glasses, and accept that this is a cost of doing grinding work.
What to wear for welding
Shade selection depends on the process and the current. The OSHA table sets minimum shades that rise with current, and suggests darker shades for comfort. Its rule of thumb is a good one. Start with a shade that is too dark to see the weld zone, then go lighter until the weld zone is visible, without going below the minimum. Gas welding, brazing and cutting use much lighter shades than arc processes, but they are not without hazard, and the infrared exposure is real.
Auto darkening helmets have made welders’ lives easier and cut down on helmet lifting, which reduces both neck strain and flash exposure. They also have their own failure points.
- Batteries and solar cells fail, and a filter with a weak power supply may not darken reliably. Check them before each shift.
- Arc sensors can be blocked by the welder’s own arm, a workpiece, or spatter on the cover lens. Out of position welding is where this bites.
- The shade and sensitivity dials get turned by the last user. Somebody switching from low current TIG to heavy stick welding without changing the setting will take a flash.
- Cracked or heavily spattered outer cover lenses get left in place far too long.
Every welder should wear clear safety spectacles under the helmet. The helmet gets lifted to check the weld, chip slag and wire brush, and that is exactly when slag flies.
Protect the people nearby
Arc eye in a fitter or a labourer working in the next bay is a sign of missing screens, not a personal failing. Welding curtains and screens should enclose the arc where practical, with the opening facing away from walkways. Anybody who must work close to welding needs appropriate filter protection, and ordinary clear spectacles do not provide it.
Making it stick on the floor
Selection is the easy part. The difficult part is getting the right protection on faces for the full duration of the task, including the thirty second jobs. The quick touch up with a grinder is where most of the eye injuries I investigated happened, because it was not considered worth putting on the full kit.
Make the correct protection available at the point of use, not in a store cupboard. Keep spares by the grinders. Replace worn items without making people justify it. Supervise the short tasks as closely as the long ones. Local regulation and a proper risk assessment for your shop decide the final specification, and an eye injury report is a reason to look at the system, not only at the person.